
information-artifact-ontology - issue #157
Use "Data Item" Terminology Consistently
Use "data item" terminology consistently throughout and improve textual definitions for several terms:
IAO_0000027 data item
- minor change to textual definition: An information content entity that is intended to be a truthful statement about something (modulo, e.g., measurement precision or other systematic errors) and is constructed/acquired by a method that reliably tends to produce (approximately) truthful statements.
- remove editor note by JAR
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000009 datum label
- change label: data item label
- add alternative term: datum label
- change textual definition: An information content entity that is part of some data item and is used to partially define the denotation of that data item.
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000003 measurement unit label
- simplify textual definition: A data item label that denotes a unit of measure.
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000100 data set
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000109 measurement datum
- change label: measurement data item
- add alternative term: measurement datum
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000032 scalar measurement datum
- change label: scalar measurement data item
- add alternative term: scalar measurement datum
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000414 mass measurement datum
- change label: mass measurement data item
- add alternative term: mass measurement datum
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000408 length measurement datum
- change label: length measurement data item
- add alternative term: length measurement datum
- change status: ready for release
IAO_0000416 time measurement datum
- change label: time measurement data item
- add alternative term: time measurement datum
IAO_0000582 time stamped measurement datum
- change label: time stamped measurement data item
- add alternative term: time stamped measurement datum
See OBI Core review notes for discussion: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Iv5VS8kbOnoQbBTt-FaJU37gK9MXkENm7pHGSk_q4d0/edit?usp=sharing
Comment #1
Posted on Mar 31, 2014 by Helpful GiraffePartially discussed on OBI/IAO call 2014-03-31.
- IAO_0000027 data item
- do not remove JAR editor note
- change status: pending final vetting
- add editor note linking to http://odontomachus.wordpress.com/2014/03/30/aboutness-objects-propositions/
- IAO_0000009 datum label
- seems problematic: Only a parent to one term in IAO. Also a parent to "categorial label" in OBI, but that term might be misplaced.
Comment #2
Posted on Apr 7, 2014 by Happy MonkeyComment deleted
Comment #3
Posted on Apr 7, 2014 by Happy MonkeyFor terms which are singular we should keep datum as data item is too general. (IMO)
Comment #4
Posted on Apr 7, 2014 by Happy MonkeyFor terms which are singular we should keep datum as data item is too general. (IMO)
Reviewing choices. datum label: No change unless new example of usage. same for anything not mentioned below.
data set -> data item set (AR agrees)
time stamped measurement data item measurement datum -> measurement data item
But check if there are unpleasant interactions with the current definition of data item set
Comment #5
Posted on Apr 7, 2014 by Happy MonkeyIdeally also change data item set to add axiom that it has min 2 data items (but this conflicts with transitive property)
Comment #6
Posted on Apr 7, 2014 by Happy MonkeyCould be done with DL-safe rules, or we could document that we want people to use has_member and then add the cardinality restriction there.
To make one more specific, e.g. mass measurement item set, use: (has_part only ('mass measurement datum' or not ('measurement data item'))).
Add editor note to this effect.
Comment #7
Posted on May 5, 2014 by Helpful GiraffeDiscussed on OBI/IAO call 2014-05-05. We will not make these changes to labels. I will make the following minor changes:
- IAO_0000027 data item
- change status: pending final vetting
- add editor note linking to http://odontomachus.wordpress.com/2014/03/30/aboutness-objects-propositions/
- IAO_0000100 data set
- add editor note: Data sets include multiple data items, a data set with zero or one entry is a contradiction, but we have chosen not to add logical axioms in support.
If there are no objections, I would also like to upgrade the curation status of these two terms:
- IAO_0000100 data set
- change status: pending final vetting
- IAO_0000109 measurement datum
- change status: pending final vetting
Comment #8
Posted on May 7, 2014 by Helpful GiraffeClosed by commit r669.
Status: Done
Labels:
Type-Defect
Priority-Medium