My favorites | Sign in
Logo
             
New issue | Search
for
| Advanced search | Search tips
Issue 1995: Can't star projects any more
59 people starred this issue and may be notified of changes. Back to list
 
Reported by alexkon, Dec 21, 2008
What steps will reproduce the problem?
Step 1. Open an unstarred project home page
Step 2. Click the star icon ("Star this project")

What is the expected output? What do you see instead?
The icon becomes yellow for a moment and the text changes, but they both
revert to the unstarred state at once. The project does not appear in my
starred projects list.

Expected the star to remain yellow and the project to show up in my profile.

What version of the product are you using? On what operating system?
Firefox 3.0.5 on Ubuntu 8.04.

Please provide any additional information below.
I currently have 71 projects starred. Is there a limit on that number?
Comment 1 by ningerso, Dec 21, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Status: Accepted
Owner: jacob13moon
Comment 2 by chris.obrien05, Jan 05, 2009
I'm having the same problem.  I just started starring projects and have very few 
starred.  The issue happened using two different devices (PC with IE v6 and T-Mobile 
G1 with Android browser) which makes me think it has something to do with the user 
profile since both used the same profile login.
Comment 3 by wjtbox01, Jan 30, 2009
to alexkon,
you have 71 stared projects?it is great,i just have 25!
i canot stared,my god!
so ,what is wrong???
Is there a limit on that number?
i think many people need an answer!!
Comment 4 by alexkon, Feb 03, 2009
I started to experience a similar problem with starring developers after having
starred 25 of them. Any chance of lifting that limit? I guess I will never need to
bookmark more than 200 projects or more than 100 developers.
Comment 5 by ningerso, Feb 03, 2009
We are currently evaluating the service impacts involved with setting a higher limit.
Labels: -Type-Defect Type-Enhancement
Comment 6 by alexkon, Feb 03, 2009
Thanks for the update. In any case, please document existing limits by showing an
error message when the user tries to star the 26th item. Silently reverting to the
unstarred state is confusing and looks like a bug.
Comment 7 by ningerso, Feb 03, 2009
I completely agree, I filed another issue for specifically fixing the feedback
mechanism, see issue 2163. Leaving this bug open to deal with the actual limit value.
Labels: Usability Component-UserProfile
Comment 8 by geekshadow, Apr 16, 2009
Got the same issue
Comment 9 by alexbevi, May 02, 2009
Same issue here as well. Since it's already being evaluated, I know there's not
benefit to throwing my "+1" in here, but I'm curious what ningerso thinks some of the
service impacts could be .....
Comment 10 by Nostariel, May 03, 2009
Wow, I thought it was a bug. So, is the limit 25? Because that's way too few. At
least 50 would be nice. Also curious about the service impacts...
Comment 11 by vijayraj.bhatt, May 09, 2009
50 is still less for the ppl who work on multiple technologies...

please make it 100...

and for the ppl who own/contribute to the projects, should get more..

i m still doubt, wht could be the problem with google in providing Unlimited stars to
eveeryone.... ???
Comment 12 by antoni.aloy, May 10, 2009
Same problem for me. As I use this as a way to bookmark the project I'm more
interested in 25 is a very slow limit. It would be nice to be able to categorize the
projects and make the star unlimited.
Comment 13 by prodevstudio, May 21, 2009
This limit is very strange. It has been over 5 months and no solution. Google must
have some very good reason for not lifting this limit.

I wonder if they are going to release a new interface?
Comment 14 by israelag...@gmail.com, May 22, 2009
Yes, it would be nice to see a fix / resolution pumped out.
Comment 15 by artdent, Jun 10, 2009
 Issue 2713  has been merged into this issue.
Comment 16 by webiest, Jun 26, 2009
I have wanted to star more projects almost 50 times now.  Please remove this limit.
Comment 17 by azmatalipasha, Jun 29, 2009
jacob13moon - any update?
Comment 18 by prodevstudio, Jun 29, 2009
I want an update on this. Leaving so many of stranded like this really shows the bad
side of Google.
Comment 19 by jacob13moon, Jun 29, 2009
I'm working on it. Removing the limit itself is simple but we have to make sure we are 
able to fetch and display updates for all the starred projects on the user Starred 
Projects page without impacting server-side/client-side latency. No guarantee, but I 
think we will be able to lift the limit in a few weeks.
Status: Started
Comment 20 by ningerso, Jul 20, 2009
 Issue 2879  has been merged into this issue.
Comment 21 by katopz, Jul 20, 2009
wow it's 1 year issue never know that ;o
Comment 22 by dkords, Jul 25, 2009
+1 on this issue.  Really an annoyance, since this is the only nice way to track a
project without joining.  Also on Firefox 3.5, and also on Flock, both on OS X 10.5.
 Has it really been a year?  I did some test using Firebug.  And in a nice response,
hidden in the HTTP response: {"starred":false,"limit":25,"limit_reached":true}


Wow, great ui.  And all this time I thought it was a stupid plugin in my browser had
somehow broken the functionality.  


So the question is, does it really code Google much to allow 25+ projects to be
watched?  Just open this up to at least 50 or 100.
Comment 23 by ningerso, Aug 03, 2009
 Issue 2895  has been merged into this issue.
Comment 24 by kos...@gmail.com, Sep 08, 2009
Instead of quickly hiding away the link to "View starred projects" when the star
limit is exceeded (currently 50), it would be nice to keep the link around so that
the user can go to the list to "unstar" projects to make room for more.
Comment 25 by sjonscom, Nov 26, 2009
+1 on this issue (i need more then 50) and not getting an errormessage when trying to
star the 51 project is a big bug imho.

If performance is the issue here, remove the dropdown thingy, perhaps create a
seperate "starred by you" page, since we don't visit that page that much, or rethink
the whole "starred project" alltogether...

Regards,
Comment 26 by ninge...@google.com, Feb 05, 2010
 Issue 3577  has been merged into this issue.
Comment 27 by rastrano, Mar 05, 2010
Any plan to extend the limit?
Comment 28 by itsnotvalid, Apr 18, 2010
I've just got the 50 items limit. Actually I am wondering why you would want to have a 
limit for this sort of things, considering that there are bookmarking services 
available for the several years (even you have Google Bookmarks.) Considering the 
amount of projects on Google Project Hosting, it is very easy for any serious user to 
have more than 50 stared project.
Comment 29 by katopz, Apr 18, 2010
2 years...and we still stuck with this limit ;p
Comment 30 by hemisfear, Apr 18, 2010
Some sort of error message would be nice as a "short term" fix given the amount of
time this bug as been open.
Comment 31 by rsepulve...@gmail.com, Apr 20, 2010
I see that's a limit. How bad... :S
Comment 32 by webiest, Apr 20, 2010
Removing this limit will make using google code much better.
Comment 33 by freewiz...@gmail.com, May 12, 2010
{"starred":false,"limit":50,"limit_reached":true}
are you kidding? this makes code.google looks like a pet project!
Comment 36 by rastrano, May 13, 2010
I can't believe that google coders are so bad to not close this bug after so much 
time ticket is open, i'm thinking now that this is not a BUG this is a FEATURE!

maybe they want keep this limit to prevent the abuse of stars and use the star count 
as an internally interesting-projects discovery engine, it is a 
"social-psychological-algorithm" (it's like a vote, but if I
have a limited number of star I will star only super-interesting projects, like if I 
have limited money I'll buy only what I really need)

I understand their purpose, but i don't agree because i want to star a lot of project 
to keep track of them, and surely i don't have time to unstarr an old entry to make 
space for a more interesting one... 

I'm using read-it-later now to keep track of interesting projects

Best regards
Stefano.
Comment 37 by titusz.pan, May 13, 2010
I wonder how many comments we can add to this issue before another "social-
psychological-algorithm" kicks in ;.)
Comment 38 by ShaneLSt...@gmail.com, May 13, 2010
By the way everyone, I found this starring issue annoying for a little while, before just making a code.google.com 
favourites folder in Chrome, and adding projects I'm interested in to this folder.  Done.
Comment 39 by katopz, May 13, 2010
i'm too far from google HQ, anyone nearby should do some protest for this or we 've
to wait until 2012, i think ;p
Comment 40 by g.rodola, May 13, 2010
Google code is a great project hosting. Personally I love it. It basically provides
everything I need in a very simple and usable way "ala google", but the lack of
constant maintenance basically makes it an abandoned software.

Once the base platform had been released 4 (or 5?) years ago very few "big"
improvements have been made aside from Mercurial integration and the user requests
are pretty much ignored, no matter if the issues keep acquiring new "stars" every day
and users complain.

Personally I'll keep sticking with Google Code also if this situation won't be
resolved (as I think) but the fact that such a beautiful platform is abandoned makes
me feel a little sad.

Comment 41 by prodevstudio, May 13, 2010
Lucky for those have not reached the 50 stars limit I think.

Only reason I am here because I follow some of the project here. I wish they moved it
across to something like github so that I would not have this same issue.

Comment 42 by ninge...@google.com, May 16, 2010
 Issue 3970  has been merged into this issue.
Comment 43 by ashwin.jayaprakash, May 16, 2010
What? A 50 project limit? That's lame and it's been open since 2008.
Comment 45 by bingo.ch...@gmail.com, Jul 06, 2010
I think projects and codes should be stared infinitely without limit.

Comment 46 by ninge...@google.com, Jul 08, 2010
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Owner: nkopch...@google.com
Sign in to add a comment

Powered by Google Project Hosting