Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

equivalent pairs error #16

Closed
ShahimEssaid opened this issue Feb 2, 2015 · 2 comments
Closed

equivalent pairs error #16

ShahimEssaid opened this issue Feb 2, 2015 · 2 comments

Comments

@ShahimEssaid
Copy link

From midori.h...@gmail.com on November 10, 2011 03:53:05

What steps will reproduce the problem?

  1. Input: (a local copy of) http://pombase.svn.sourceforge.net/viewvc/pombase/phenotype_ontology/fypo_edit.obo revision 239
  2. Run Oort with default settings; output to local testing directory

    What is the expected output? What do you see instead?

    Expected: release files as described in documentation (still learning about specifics of those files' content ..)

    Got: popup error box saying "Internal error: will not release inconsistent ontology unless forced!" (0.3.3 beta) or "Internal error: will not release ontology with equivalent pairs unless forced!" (0.3.4 beta)

    The log file contains many lines like these:
    "Class FYPO:0000370 has a self reference in its logical definition."
    "2011-11-10 11:03:05 ERROR Equiv:EquivalentClasses(<http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/FYPO_0000071> <http://purl.obolibrary.org/obo/FYPO_0000126> )"

    But there's no self reference in the FYPO:0000370 stanza, and it's not obvious if there's a self reference resulting from transitivity, implied links, etc. And FYPO:0000071 is_a FYPO:0000126 -- they're not identical, so I think they're not "equivalent".

    What version of the product are you using? On what operating system?

    I tried 0.3.3-beta and 0.3.4-beta, and got essentially the same results, except for minor message wording differences.
    Mac OS X version 10.6.8

    Please provide any additional information below.

Original issue: http://code.google.com/p/owltools/issues/detail?id=16

@ShahimEssaid
Copy link
Author

From HDie...@lbl.gov on December 02, 2011 17:02:25

In OORT-0.3.5-beta, the tool lists all the equivalent classes. Is this more helpful? For your ontology (rev 239) the listing is as follows:

EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000120 "abnormal spindle" FYPO:0000132 "abnormal septum disassembly" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000108 "sensitive to menadione" FYPO:0000110 "sensitive to pravastatin" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000101 "sensitive to chlorpropham" FYPO:0000110 "sensitive to pravastatin" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000110 "sensitive to pravastatin" FYPO:0000127 "increased sensitivity to chemical" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000120 "abnormal spindle" FYPO:0000132 "abnormal septum disassembly" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000110 "sensitive to pravastatin" FYPO:0000127 "increased sensitivity to chemical" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000108 "sensitive to menadione" FYPO:0000127 "increased sensitivity to chemical" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000101 "sensitive to chlorpropham" FYPO:0000127 "increased sensitivity to chemical" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000071 "resistance to aureobasidin A" FYPO:0000126 "increased resistance to chemical" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000567 "decreased septation" FYPO:0000639 "delayed septation" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000108 "sensitive to menadione" FYPO:0000110 "sensitive to pravastatin" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000101 "sensitive to chlorpropham" FYPO:0000108 "sensitive to menadione" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000108 "sensitive to menadione" FYPO:0000127 "increased sensitivity to chemical" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000101 "sensitive to chlorpropham" FYPO:0000110 "sensitive to pravastatin" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000101 "sensitive to chlorpropham" FYPO:0000108 "sensitive to menadione" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000101 "sensitive to chlorpropham" FYPO:0000127 "increased sensitivity to chemical" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000567 "decreased septation" FYPO:0000639 "delayed septation" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000405 "normal cell cycle progression through mitotic G2/M phase transition" FYPO:0000411 "normal cell cycle progression" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000619 "mitotic cell cycle arrest in late anaphase" FYPO:0000620 "mitotic cell cycle arrest in metaphase" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000405 "normal cell cycle progression through mitotic G2/M phase transition" FYPO:0000411 "normal cell cycle progression" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000619 "mitotic cell cycle arrest in late anaphase" FYPO:0000620 "mitotic cell cycle arrest in metaphase" )
EquivalentClasses(FYPO:0000071 "resistance to aureobasidin A" FYPO:0000126 "increased resistance to chemical" )

@ShahimEssaid
Copy link
Author

From HDie...@lbl.gov on September 18, 2012 15:29:43

Status: Done

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant