xml, plaintext, and other elements' innerHTML cannot be safely inserted into another element's innerHTML

Effect

If an implementation allows injecting of innerHTML from one element into another, the deprecated XMP and LISTING tags' content is treated as CDATA, and so their innerHTML is not escaped as normal.

Background

http://www.freesoft.org/CIE/RFC/1866/37.htm describes the XMP and LISTING tags' content as preformatted text. The HTML 3.2 spec defines their content as %literal.

The full list as defined in HTML3.2 is:

• listing
• plaintext
• xmp

Also problematic are

• option
• script
• style
• textarea
• title

Assumptions

The document is an HTML document, not XHTML.

An implementation allows innerHTML to be extracted from one DOM node to be injected into another without rewriting.

Versions

All

Example

// Does not require programmatic creation of a script tag
var xmp = document.createElement('xmp');
xmp.appendChild(
    document.createTextNode(
        "<script>alert('cookie=' + document.cookie)</script>"));
// If the implementation assumes this is safe
var html = xmp.innerHTML;
// then it might allow this
document.writeln(html);