Obsolete
Status Update
Comments
m....@gmail.com <m....@gmail.com> #2
I want it too...
thanks!
thanks!
ri...@gmail.com <ri...@gmail.com> #3
I second that. The name tagging feature is excactly what I have been waiting for.
Now if I could jusrt access it through the API. Pretty Please!
Now if I could jusrt access it through the API. Pretty Please!
th...@gmail.com <th...@gmail.com> #4
would be nice to have!
ja...@gmail.com <ja...@gmail.com> #5
I'll fourth that!
os...@gmail.com <os...@gmail.com> #6
So many amazing app's could be done!!
Imaging integrating that info into your Contacts App of your prefered desktop!
Imaging integrating that info into your Contacts App of your prefered desktop!
ja...@gmail.com <ja...@gmail.com> #7
want it be possible to guess the api from picasaweb forms?
be...@gmail.com <be...@gmail.com> #8
Both read and write access, please.
pe...@gmail.com <pe...@gmail.com> #9
This is a great idea. It will enable some very useful applications.
hi...@gmail.com <hi...@gmail.com> #10
I too would like to see this data available through the API.
sa...@gmail.com <sa...@gmail.com> #11
This API is just what I was hoping existed. Please make this available!
ch...@gmail.com <ch...@gmail.com> #12
I would like also to access this through the API. It would be cool to be able to
upload a picture and find who is on the picture. A lot of applications can use this
to make cool new stuf.
upload a picture and find who is on the picture. A lot of applications can use this
to make cool new stuf.
cs...@gmail.com <cs...@gmail.com> #13
Please add this to the API!!!
fk...@gmail.com <fk...@gmail.com> #14
Wondering when it comes out!!
ki...@gmail.com <ki...@gmail.com> #15
Seems a shame to have this functionality and not expose it via the API.
st...@gmail.com <st...@gmail.com> #16
Obviously what people are too scared to mention is the possibility of exporting their
albums using this data to Facebook. Which I think would be awesome. Also being able
to drag your albums kicking and screaming out of Facebook into Picasa would be
amazing too. I imagine a little third party service/software that manages a lookup
table between contacts and Facebook friends. Or perhaps even adding the Facebook
profile url in to my Google contact details under an "other" entry would be able to
facilitate the lookup without utilising a local or cloud based third party lookup.
I have a dream whereby I can view my albums with all the same contextual data such as
"name tags", comments etc in any place - desktop/Facebook/Picasa/my own website.
Help us make this happen Google!
I can see myself touching up, describing and tagging my photo's on Picasa on my
desktop. Uploading these to Picasa Web in all their full featured glory. Then at the
click of a button firing these photo's straight into Facebook, with comments and tags
all in place.
This all leads to me paying for more storage space in Picasa. $$$ for you guys :-)
Thanks for your time,
Steve Daniels
albums using this data to Facebook. Which I think would be awesome. Also being able
to drag your albums kicking and screaming out of Facebook into Picasa would be
amazing too. I imagine a little third party service/software that manages a lookup
table between contacts and Facebook friends. Or perhaps even adding the Facebook
profile url in to my Google contact details under an "other" entry would be able to
facilitate the lookup without utilising a local or cloud based third party lookup.
I have a dream whereby I can view my albums with all the same contextual data such as
"name tags", comments etc in any place - desktop/Facebook/Picasa/my own website.
Help us make this happen Google!
I can see myself touching up, describing and tagging my photo's on Picasa on my
desktop. Uploading these to Picasa Web in all their full featured glory. Then at the
click of a button firing these photo's straight into Facebook, with comments and tags
all in place.
This all leads to me paying for more storage space in Picasa. $$$ for you guys :-)
Thanks for your time,
Steve Daniels
to...@gmail.com <to...@gmail.com> #17
Any progress? When is it coming?
Tomas
Tomas
ed...@gmail.com <ed...@gmail.com> #18
Would be great
as...@gmail.com <as...@gmail.com> #19
I would like also to access this through the API as many great applications can be
developed on this
developed on this
ju...@gmail.com <ju...@gmail.com> #20
I want it too.
mg...@gmail.com <mg...@gmail.com> #22
i would love to be able to upload photos easily from Picasa to Facebook and maintain
tagging...
tagging...
li...@gmail.com <li...@gmail.com> #23
I need this issue.
is...@gmail.com <is...@gmail.com> #24
waiting too...
bs...@gmail.com <bs...@gmail.com> #25
any idea when this is going to be available??
jf...@youtube.com <jf...@youtube.com> #26
To collect some more information on the use case here-
I am guessing the actions you would all like to see in the API is something like -
* Show list of all recognized subjects (faces) in the API
* Filter above list to subjects without a name
* Add/Change the name associated with a particular subject
* Search all photos in album or user account that contain a particular subject
Does this sound like a pretty exhaustive list?
I am guessing the actions you would all like to see in the API is something like -
* Show list of all recognized subjects (faces) in the API
* Filter above list to subjects without a name
* Add/Change the name associated with a particular subject
* Search all photos in album or user account that contain a particular subject
Does this sound like a pretty exhaustive list?
mf...@gmail.com <mf...@gmail.com> #27
Yes, it does. It seems the data backend stores quite detailed information about
recognized faces, such as the region in a photo where a face has been recognized, and
probably also scoring data indicating the confidence in a recognition. It might be
that some users would like to have access to these data, but I and probably most
others would be EXTREMELY happy getting the functionality you describe.
Actually, for what it's worth, for me it would suffice to get the names returned as
additional tags when querying all tags for a photo.
recognized faces, such as the region in a photo where a face has been recognized, and
probably also scoring data indicating the confidence in a recognition. It might be
that some users would like to have access to these data, but I and probably most
others would be EXTREMELY happy getting the functionality you describe.
Actually, for what it's worth, for me it would suffice to get the names returned as
additional tags when querying all tags for a photo.
jo...@gmx.de <jo...@gmx.de> #28
@jfisher: yes, and please also make it possible to extract the rectangle defined by the
user/algorithm who tagged the person out of the image. Meaning it should not only be
possible to fetch all images containing a certain person, but also only the marked
faces of that person.
user/algorithm who tagged the person out of the image. Meaning it should not only be
possible to fetch all images containing a certain person, but also only the marked
faces of that person.
ch...@gmail.com <ch...@gmail.com> #29
That looks pretty complete. Ideally the list of recognized subjects would contain
the location and size of each recognized subject. Also the ability to add subjects
manually where none was found, or where they have been previously identified via
another method.
Has any work been done on a standard metadata format to store subjects(faces) in the
original files? The capability to identify faces seems to be popping up in several
places, but as far as I know, none of them are adding the metadata back to the
original files.
the location and size of each recognized subject. Also the ability to add subjects
manually where none was found, or where they have been previously identified via
another method.
Has any work been done on a standard metadata format to store subjects(faces) in the
original files? The capability to identify faces seems to be popping up in several
places, but as far as I know, none of them are adding the metadata back to the
original files.
li...@gmail.com <li...@gmail.com> #30
For completeness, I think there's two aspects here: first is just face region data
and the second is an API to access Picasa Web's automatic face detection.
In terms of just face region (i.e. regions that have been named by a user either from
automatic detection or manually drawing a bounding box), face data API should:
1) Provide CRUD operations for face regions (including bounding box, coordinates, and
name)
2) List all face regions in a particular image (plus reasonable filters)
3) Search all photos for a particular name
In terms of Picasa Web's facial recognition algorithm:
4) List all face regions in a photo identified by the algorithm
5) List all names of persons the algorithm has matched photos to (presumably, Google
has some kind of probability data on this match as well that could be returned)
6) Ability to name regions automatically identified (or mark regions as "Not a Face",
"Ignore", etc)
I think #1, #2, and #3 are the pieces of functionality that most developers want. #4
might be next on the priority list followed by #5. #6 I imagine would just be a
combination of #1/#4 except with an additional ability to provide feedback back to
the facial recognition algorithm for false positives.
and the second is an API to access Picasa Web's automatic face detection.
In terms of just face region (i.e. regions that have been named by a user either from
automatic detection or manually drawing a bounding box), face data API should:
1) Provide CRUD operations for face regions (including bounding box, coordinates, and
name)
2) List all face regions in a particular image (plus reasonable filters)
3) Search all photos for a particular name
In terms of Picasa Web's facial recognition algorithm:
4) List all face regions in a photo identified by the algorithm
5) List all names of persons the algorithm has matched photos to (presumably, Google
has some kind of probability data on this match as well that could be returned)
6) Ability to name regions automatically identified (or mark regions as "Not a Face",
"Ignore", etc)
I think #1, #2, and #3 are the pieces of functionality that most developers want. #4
might be next on the priority list followed by #5. #6 I imagine would just be a
combination of #1/#4 except with an additional ability to provide feedback back to
the facial recognition algorithm for false positives.
rb...@gmail.com <rb...@gmail.com> #31
Does the new 2.0 api have support for this?
sh...@gmail.com <sh...@gmail.com> #32
Is similar functionality sought to be implemented in desktop version?
gv...@gmail.com <gv...@gmail.com> #33
It would be great to just get the list of people in the photo, analogous to TagData
or TagEntry. I.e. the first item from comment 26:
* Show list of all recognized subjects (faces) in the API
The other features could come later, as far as I'm concerned.
or TagEntry. I.e. the first item from comment 26:
* Show list of all recognized subjects (faces) in the API
The other features could come later, as far as I'm concerned.
lh...@gmail.com <lh...@gmail.com> #34
I need this too,
please implement this Google :)
please implement this Google :)
sh...@gmail.com <sh...@gmail.com> #35
What are "subjectids" how can a list of "subjectids" be obtained?
ca...@gmail.com <ca...@gmail.com> #36
this would be totally awesome id love to be able to work with this data through api
al...@gmail.com <al...@gmail.com> #37
Any progress? When is it coming?
sh...@gmail.com <sh...@gmail.com> #38
I need this too! gogogo!
ca...@gmail.com <ca...@gmail.com> #39
like think about it facebook auto tagging and like all kinds of crazy cool fun
br...@gmail.com <br...@gmail.com> #40
Facial recognition would be of great value to software that integrates photo
libraries with genealogical information. Many users have large libraries of photos of
people, singly or in groups, that are important genealogically. Ancestors or
relatives for example.
To be useful the API would have to provide the full contact information and the
region in the photo of the recognized face.
You could then do a tree that shows the relationships of the persons in the photo
with thumbnails from the photo of the recognized faces. Or draw rectangles on the
displayed photo with name labels.
With the new facial recognition feature, users are organizing their libraries and
identifying faces. But with no API for access, and no tags in the photos that can be
recognized by other programs, the information is locked in the Picasa system. You can
manually add a name tag to each photo that is in the face album, but this does not
tell which face is which. So near and yet so far ...
libraries with genealogical information. Many users have large libraries of photos of
people, singly or in groups, that are important genealogically. Ancestors or
relatives for example.
To be useful the API would have to provide the full contact information and the
region in the photo of the recognized face.
You could then do a tree that shows the relationships of the persons in the photo
with thumbnails from the photo of the recognized faces. Or draw rectangles on the
displayed photo with name labels.
With the new facial recognition feature, users are organizing their libraries and
identifying faces. But with no API for access, and no tags in the photos that can be
recognized by other programs, the information is locked in the Picasa system. You can
manually add a name tag to each photo that is in the face album, but this does not
tell which face is which. So near and yet so far ...
ba...@gmail.com <ba...@gmail.com> #41
Hi Google,
Please release (to developers) Picasa - Face Data - Access .
You will surely get many open source application and ideas.
You can also organize some code competition and get ideas.
All are Waiting for quick solution (Face API) !
-www.BaljeetSingh.Net
Please release (to developers) Picasa - Face Data - Access .
You will surely get many open source application and ideas.
You can also organize some code competition and get ideas.
All are Waiting for quick solution (Face API) !
-
mr...@gmail.com <mr...@gmail.com> #42
It's been over a year since this was suggested. Is this feature coming? If so when?
This would be incredibly useful to my organization and would mean that we would be
writing a plugin to picasa rather than trying to duplicate all of that work.
This would be incredibly useful to my organization and would mean that we would be
writing a plugin to picasa rather than trying to duplicate all of that work.
be...@gmail.com <be...@gmail.com> #43
3) Search all photos for a particular name
3.1) Search list of names with any photo
3.2.) Search all photos for a name (or part of a name) and any tag.
3.1) Search list of names with any photo
3.2.) Search all photos for a name (or part of a name) and any tag.
se...@gmail.com <se...@gmail.com> #44
I would use a face recognition API too!
ik...@gmail.com <ik...@gmail.com> #45
this would be great thing!
t....@gmail.com <t....@gmail.com> #47
Hey wen will face detection be exposed in api.ny idea??
ko...@gmail.com <ko...@gmail.com> #48
this would be awesome
ko...@gmail.com <ko...@gmail.com> #49
this would be awesome
hu...@gmail.com <hu...@gmail.com> #50
I want it.
jo...@gmail.com <jo...@gmail.com> #51
I want it too!
ni...@gmail.com <ni...@gmail.com> #52
Would be a great addition to the API.
gl...@gmail.com <gl...@gmail.com> #53
Need to be implemented!
be...@gmail.com <be...@gmail.com> #54
I'm surprised its not available... please make it available.
sr...@gmail.com <sr...@gmail.com> #55
waiting for this api...Pls release
sr...@gmail.com <sr...@gmail.com> #56
waiting for this api...Pls release
cc...@gmail.com <cc...@gmail.com> #57
please.....
mo...@gmail.com <mo...@gmail.com> #58
No more informations about this feature in API ?
ro...@gmail.com <ro...@gmail.com> #59
Please! It is so unlike the Google we love to make this data inaccessible.
ha...@gmail.com <ha...@gmail.com> #60
common google! make this happen. I want this in my phone client!
wa...@gmail.com <wa...@gmail.com> #61
This has been open for ~2.5 years now and is by far the most starred issue. And only one response (comment 26) from a project member? Lots of clarifying comments since then.
Like others, I want to see a list of faces. That list needs to include the identity of the person and the location of the box around that persons face.
The ability to add, update, change stuff would be nice, as would searching and filters. But I really just want the list with locations.
Like others, I want to see a list of faces. That list needs to include the identity of the person and the location of the box around that persons face.
The ability to add, update, change stuff would be nice, as would searching and filters. But I really just want the list with locations.
de...@gmail.com <de...@gmail.com> #62
waiting for the API!!!
mo...@gmail.com <mo...@gmail.com> #63
In response to comment 26 .. yes to all of these
and please add:
1. return name and other data in response to picture-based query of picasa web-albums
2. compressed (facial-features) query for embedded clients ex. security cameras against picasa web-albums
3. return parameters such as sex, age, smile, blink, race, facial-symmetry ... (beauty?) in response to query to picasa web-albums
4. return percentage matches for queries to picasa web-albums
5. allow logical queries of picasa web-albums ex. return pix of bill && monica && ^hillary
6. return "best-picture" of an individual in response to a query using name or picture-data ... could be based on votes, tags or
7. allow "best-picture" to be back-substituted into current image and patched ... replace a person who has their eyes closed, face partially occluded etc.
and please add:
1. return name and other data in response to picture-based query of picasa web-albums
2. compressed (facial-features) query for embedded clients ex. security cameras against picasa web-albums
3. return parameters such as sex, age, smile, blink, race, facial-symmetry ... (beauty?) in response to query to picasa web-albums
4. return percentage matches for queries to picasa web-albums
5. allow logical queries of picasa web-albums ex. return pix of bill && monica && ^hillary
6. return "best-picture" of an individual in response to a query using name or picture-data ... could be based on votes, tags or
7. allow "best-picture" to be back-substituted into current image and patched ... replace a person who has their eyes closed, face partially occluded etc.
ni...@gmail.com <ni...@gmail.com> #64
This sounds extremely useful for my needs.
m0...@gmail.com <m0...@gmail.com> #65
Where is it already?!
vu...@gmail.com <vu...@gmail.com> #67
come on, where is it already??
Please give us some feedback
Please give us some feedback
es...@gmail.com <es...@gmail.com> #68
Me too, I hope for it.
I think they dont make it because it is not good for Privacy.
Imagine the following:
1.) You make an invitaion for an public event on an Social Network.
2.) The Users will connect somehow to that invitaion (Like, +1, Join, ...)
3.) Now you have personal profiledata of that person and an image
4.) You place an cam on the entrance of that event ....
5.) Now you have an complete personal profile of the persons who visit the event.
6.) Now you can act .... Play the right sound, increase the price for some special offer, .... just joking.
I think the wishlist of the API is quite complete.
For the above mentioned Applikation I would need the ability to POST an Image (of one or more Persons) and get Face information of the Person(s) on it.
Does any Google Developer give us an statement about that API?
Is there a way to use that function in the Picasa Desktop (COM)?
Is there any other Company who offers it?
I think they dont make it because it is not good for Privacy.
Imagine the following:
1.) You make an invitaion for an public event on an Social Network.
2.) The Users will connect somehow to that invitaion (Like, +1, Join, ...)
3.) Now you have personal profiledata of that person and an image
4.) You place an cam on the entrance of that event ....
5.) Now you have an complete personal profile of the persons who visit the event.
6.) Now you can act .... Play the right sound, increase the price for some special offer, .... just joking.
I think the wishlist of the API is quite complete.
For the above mentioned Applikation I would need the ability to POST an Image (of one or more Persons) and get Face information of the Person(s) on it.
Does any Google Developer give us an statement about that API?
Is there a way to use that function in the Picasa Desktop (COM)?
Is there any other Company who offers it?
da...@gmail.com <da...@gmail.com> #69
I'm keen to exploit this functionality to enhance analysing old family photographs on a web site so would like to know how to get this issue moving forward as it seems Google have been sitting on the subject for nearly 3 years.
ol...@gmail.com <ol...@gmail.com> #70
What does this mean?
Status: 1367479
Status: 1367479
eh...@gmail.com <eh...@gmail.com> #71
I just want to retrieve a list of photos with a specified people name from all photos of my own albuns. I don't think it will be bad for privacy.
vu...@gmail.com <vu...@gmail.com> #73
nice find by 72 'D'Arcy Rittich'
Thx!!
Thx!!
go...@gmail.com <go...@gmail.com> #74
my want is simple compared to most here i'd just like access to the list of photos already easily displayable here
https://plus.google.com/u/0/photos/of/105840032109694933186
but via the picasa api (or even a g+ one)
but an rss/xml/rest or other easily machine readable format seems unavailable thus far
its looking likely that i may have to decipher the js and essentially 'screen scrape' the urls of the pics (which is all i want)
but via the picasa api (or even a g+ one)
but an rss/xml/rest or other easily machine readable format seems unavailable thus far
its looking likely that i may have to decipher the js and essentially 'screen scrape' the urls of the pics (which is all i want)
ha...@gmail.com <ha...@gmail.com> #75
I have a new storage capacity just bought, for downloading a video clip of my own
Picasa Web.
I hope your help me find a solution to download a video clip yours.
Note: I have a mobile iPhone and also Web Allbeckasa application,
Picasa Web.
I hope your help me find a solution to download a video clip yours.
Note: I have a mobile iPhone and also Web Allbeckasa application,
f....@gmail.com <f....@gmail.com> #76
is google still doesnt provide the developers with face tags data from photos?
If not, is there any way to access that? I need it for my thesis.
If not, is there any way to access that? I need it for my thesis.
et...@gmail.com <et...@gmail.com> #77
I need face tags in API too.
ma...@google.com <ma...@google.com> #78
We are marking this issue as Obsolete as this issue tracker is no longer monitored by the team responsible for this API service.
If this is a technical issue you still need assistance with, please post to the appropriate tag on Stack Overflow:http://www.stackoverflow.com
You can also visithttp://developers.google.com and locate the particular product for up-to-date support options.
If this is a technical issue you still need assistance with, please post to the appropriate tag on Stack Overflow:
You can also visit
Description
New Picasaweb Faces capabilities are great. API access to this data could
allow some great extensions to the current interface.
To many cool projects to list, please just let me at the data...
thanks,
Chip