My favorites | Sign in
Google
          
New issue | Search
for
| Advanced search | Search tips
Issue 110: Add - DateTime stamp when user added video to his/her favorites
20 people starred this issue and may be notified of changes. Back to list
Status:  Fixed
Owner:  jfis...@youtube.com
Closed:  Oct 2008
Type-Enhancement
Priority-Low
API-YouTube


Sign in to add a comment
 
Reported by marekmarecki2007, Sep 14, 2007
Please list service(s) affected YouTube

What steps will reproduce the problem?
1. Feed data by API
2. There is no information about when video was added to favorites by user

What is the expected output? What do you see instead?
Time when user add video to his/her favorites 

What version of the product are you using? On what operating system?
Current Google API

 
Comment 1 by api.stephaniel, Sep 14, 2007
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Labels: -Type-Defect Type-Enhancement API-YouTube
Comment 2 by api.stephaniel, Sep 19, 2007
858493
Comment 3 by sav74sac, Oct 21, 2007
I vote for this issue.

I cannot use this data without the dates - as it makes mash-ups with other feeds
impossible.
Comment 4 by kjello, Nov 18, 2007
Any news on this? The videos on a users favorites page *are* sorted correctly, so the information must be there 
and the feed is just being wrongly constructed. I'd love to see this fixed.
Comment 5 by chrismtaggart, Dec 15, 2007
+1 for this
Comment 6 by api.stephaniel, Jan 08, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Status: Prioritized
Labels: -Priority-Medium Priority-Low
Comment 7 by sav74sac, Jan 08, 2008
Sorry to see this is considered low priority.

It's in the top 10% of issues if you sort by # of stars/votes.

I'm really looking forward to this issue being fixed so I can start using YouTube 
favorites in mashups. 

So far, I can use all other google data in mashups because they have 'published' 
data (e.g. Calendar, Reader, Blogger, Picasa)

YouTube Favorites is the only google feed with a problem here.
Comment 8 by ty...@tylerhunt.com, Jan 17, 2008
+1

I'm waiting on this feature before I integrate YouTube videos into my application. I have currently integrated RSS, 
Flickr, and Twitter, but without the date information on favorites (and playlists as well...) I'm going to have to 
hold off for now.
Comment 9 by msittig, Feb 01, 2008
Implementers of Facebook-style personal newsfeeds (see FriendFeed, Escaloop, etc)
have no way to integrate Youtube favorites until this feature is added, aside from
constantly scraping user favorite pages to generate their own approximate "added" times.
Comment 10 by rythie, Mar 03, 2008
The API largely un-usable for my purposes without this feature.
Comment 11 by api.jfisher, Mar 18, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Status: 858493
Comment 12 by jrsmith, Mar 19, 2008
I'm also eagerly awaiting this feature. Like many of the users above, I can't do
anything with the favorites feed without the date the video was favorited. I hope the
priority on this gets bumped up. If this information isn't being stored, let us know
so we can stop hoping.
Comment 13 by sav74sac, Apr 17, 2008
Come on guys, pretty pleeeeeeeease? :-D
Comment 14 by vafh-...@virginia.edu, Apr 30, 2008
+1  
Comment 15 by Zentrice, May 04, 2008
I don't see why it's missing in the first place. Gets my vote!
Comment 16 by marcdroberts, Jul 27, 2008
Please implement this, i can't use the feeds from favorites or playlists without this.
Comment 17 by talkinsmack, Aug 09, 2008
It makes no sense how there could be a user favorite feed without date added
included. I'm agreeing with sav74sac that this omitted information makes this feed
absolutely useless.
Comment 18 by shaun.webster, Sep 04, 2008
Yes this feed NEED a user_added date with it or its useless.
Comment 19 by sav74sac, Sep 05, 2008
Friendfeed supports it already (from YouTube)... so Google should have it.
Comment 20 by joeymilleris, Sep 10, 2008
I'd like to see this implemented too
Comment 21 by mearymix89, Oct 03, 2008
Don't see why it is low priority, for something as simple as this, it would take very
little time to fix, so why hasn't it been done? Please could this be fixed.
Comment 23 by jrsmith, Oct 12, 2008
It's been over a year and this still hasn't been implemented. I've cobbled together a
workaround that can approximate the "favorited" date. It's not exact. I currently
have the polling interval set to 20 minutes, so the favorited date can be off by as
much as that, but it's better than nothing.

All this does is basically make a copy of the RSS feed from Youtube and replace their
published date with a UTC date for the estimated favorited date.

It's still a work in progress and VERY bare-bones, but you guys are welcome to test
it out and make any suggestions. The address is http://www.jrsmith.net/lab/youtube_feeds/
Comment 24 by jfis...@youtube.com, Oct 20, 2008
For V2 the atom:published and atom:updated reflect the time the favorite was added.
There is a new tag inside of <media:group> called <yt:uploaded> that gives the
datetime that the video was uploaded.
Status: Fixed
Owner: jfis...@youtube.com
Comment 25 by jrsmith, Oct 20, 2008
I don't see any of these changes reflected in the feed. Is it something that will be
rolled out soon?
Comment 26 by sav74sac, Oct 20, 2008
Yay - finally fixed. Thanks!
Comment 27 by sav74sac, Oct 20, 2008
It's there... in the <pubDate> and <published> tags.

Try this for your feed, replacing your username in the URL:
http://gdata.youtube.com/feeds/api/users/<username>/favorites?v=2
Comment 28 by jrsmith, Oct 20, 2008
Ah, I was missing the version query parameter. Thanks for pointing that out.
Comment 29 by Fraiponts, Oct 21, 2008
Major thanks for fixing this!
Sign in to add a comment