My favorites | Sign in
Logo
             
New issue | Search
for
| Advanced search | Search tips
Issue 114: Text boxes lose typing
51 people starred this issue and may be notified of changes. Back to list
Status:  Duplicate
Merged:  issue 3811
Owner:  jon@chromium.org
Closed:  Dec 2008
Cc:  anantha@chromium.org, karen@chromium.org
Type-Bug
Pri-1
OS-All
Area-WebKit
Mstone-1.1
Usability


Sign in to add a comment
 
Reported by silkcom, Sep 02, 2008
Product Version      : 0.2.149.27 (1583)
URLs (if applicable) : http://www.autohotkey.com/forum/posting.php?
mode=newtopic&f=1 
Other browsers tested: Firefox
Add OK or FAIL after other browsers where you have tested this issue:
Safari 3:
    Firefox 3: OK
IE 7:

What steps will reproduce the problem?
1. Start filling in an issue into the text area
2. Make a correction to the text that has been entered
3.

What is the expected result?
The textbox should always show all the characters that are in the text 
area.

What happens instead?
Some of the characters that are still in the text area are hidden.  They 
blank out and randomly (to me) come back.  They are always still there, but 
they are hidden.

Please provide any additional information below. Attach a screenshot if 
possible.
It's possible that it's specific to Autohotkey's forum, but I highly doubt 
it.  If you'd like to get a Wink video of the issue I can show it no 
problem.
Comment 1 by apostolo...@gmail.com, Sep 02, 2008
[CONFIRMED]

It happens most of the times on username/password fields that the browser 
"remembers".
Comment 2 by t.billep, Sep 03, 2008
i also have this problem. using dokuwiki and the textarea field
Comment 3 by angusthefuzz, Sep 03, 2008
The proboards.com phpBB forum also has this problem.  The text field appears to lag 
behind the typing, causing some text to disappear as it naturally wraps to the next 
line.   
Comment 4 by darkbls, Sep 03, 2008
Same behavior in a dokuwiki page modification. Happend more often after a text paste 
in the textarea
Comment 5 by saul.rennison, Sep 03, 2008
I can also confirm this in phpBB forums "Quick-reply".
Comment 6 by giancarlo.todone, Sep 04, 2008
Same problem with me (winxp home SP3); seems to happen on large text area only (e.g.
Gmail "new mail" one as well as vbulletin ones)
Comment 7 by maft.morley, Sep 04, 2008
it tends to be 'textarea' asopposed to a form input element of type='text'

MaFt
Comment 8 by aedapp, Sep 04, 2008
I had problems with dokuwiki and with Wordpress (also since i'm using a BiDi input 
[for Hebrew]). The BiDi could be a separate bug.
Comment 9 by WarrenAlpert, Sep 04, 2008
Here is a video of it for me: http://screencast.com/t/St9MY0V64EZ .
Comment 10 by marco.montel, Sep 04, 2008
Also for me same behavior in dokuwiki. If you resize the textarea text will reappear.
Comment 11 by goodguy20k, Sep 04, 2008
I, and several friends, also have had this problem with the textarea of a phpBB 
forum. Seems like just about everywhere else it's working fine.
Comment 12 by matt.godbolt, Sep 05, 2008
I've been able to find a minimal reproducible case for this - it seems PHP has a 
TEXTAREA inside a SPAN tag (which is somewhat nonsensical).  Chrome doesn't render 
this properly.  See attached html page.
text_box.html
299 bytes Download
Comment 13 by papashou, Sep 05, 2008
I can confirm this bug exists as well - and would very much like to fix it (It's a 
hassle editing TWiki documents with Chrome)
Comment 14 by rig9919, Sep 10, 2008
>Here is a video of it for me: http://screencast.com/t/St9MY0V64EZ .

That happens for me too on a phpBB forum.
Comment 15 by evan@chromium.org, Sep 10, 2008
Thanks for the awesome bug report (with screencast, even) and repro case!
Summary: Text boxes lose typing
Status: Untriaged
Labels: -Area-Unknown Area-Compat
Comment 16 by robman94, Sep 19, 2008
I was just about to report this bug too, but instead I'll just confirm that it also 
happens for me when I try to post replies in a phpbb forum.

The work-around is to highlight all of the text as this will usually correct the 
display.  Sometimes you will also need to do a line break after the last character.
Comment 17 by wubber, Sep 29, 2008
I can also confirm this as a bug on phpBB forums and gmail on Vista + XP SP3.
Comment 18 by blackboxxx, Oct 10, 2008
I can also confirm the bug on vBulletin boards using Chrome 0.3.154.0
Comment 19 by nearaz, Oct 10, 2008
I can confirm the issue on phpBB forums running on forum.unity3d.com using Chrome 0.3.154.0, on XP SP3.
Comment 20 by rmaniacnyc, Oct 12, 2008
For me there is not always a blinking cursor in text box. Such as when using facebook 
posting a posted items, and typing in  the  description or the comment box.
Comment 21 by Hunnter, Oct 20, 2008
Actually, this also happens on the Myspace forums too.

The only way i have found to fix this is either wait for a few seconds, or just 
highlight everything.

It also tends to happen whenever a word gets word-wrapped to the next line when 
typing a sentence, part of the word you were typing (the parts before the wrap from 
what i remember) become invisible.
Comment 23 by patrick@chromium.org, Oct 22, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Status: Available
Labels: -Mstone-1.0 Mstone-1.1
Comment 24 by vbendeb, Oct 30, 2008
This happens with different revisions of http://www.phpbb.com based forums.

Clicking in the window outside the messed up text box fixes the contents.

These forums are quite popular, and Chrome is getting very low praise from all those 
users.
Comment 25 by Riel.Notermans, Nov 03, 2008
Changing text-size (ctrl- scroll up and down) fixes the bad rendering too, it's a 
useful fast workaround. Just anything that would 're-render' the current text on 
screen.

Interesting that this textbox is not suffering that problem.


Comment 27 by nathan.kingsman, Nov 13, 2008
Text-areas in Juno webmail had this problem, where an unfinished word reaches the 
right edge of a textarea, and the whole word is wrapped to the second line, and the 
first couple letters disappear.  Moving the mouse cursor and selecting text where the 
letters would have been make the letters visible again.
Comment 29 by jdomnitz, Nov 19, 2008
community server has the same problem with quick reply
Comment 30 by anantha@chromium.org, Nov 20, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Owner: jasneet
Cc: anan...@chromium.org
Comment 31 by jon@chromium.org, Nov 21, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Labels: -Pri-2 -Area-Compat Pri-1 Area-WebKit Usability
Comment 32 by jasneet@chromium.org, Nov 24, 2008
Issue reproducible with Chrome 0.4.154.25 on url : 
http://www.autohotkey.com/forum/posting.php?mode=newtopic&f=1

Issue not reproducible on urls : 
http://forum.dokuwiki.org/
http://support.proboards.com/
http://www.vbulletin.com/forum/
http://forums.myspace.com/

Please provide url so as to reproduce the issue.


Status: Untriaged
Owner: ---
Comment 33 by mixsynth, Dec 03, 2008
I can confirm this bug while adding/editing posts on phpBB 2.0.22 boards using Chrome
0.4.154.29.
Comment 34 by jasneet@chromium.org, Dec 03, 2008
mixsynth: Please provide url to reproduce the issue.
Comment 35 by saul.rennison, Dec 03, 2008
Any quick reply text box on:
http://forums.mattie.info/cs/forums/

Comment 36 by progame, Dec 03, 2008
confirmed, doesn't always happen but if i try to add characters somewhere between the 
words i already entered... if it doesn't happen at my first try it will happen by the 
4th (each time pointing the caret with the mouse to a new location)
Comment 37 by jon@chromium.org, Dec 03, 2008
I believe this is fixed in the nightly builds.  It would help a lot if someone could 
download the nightly build from http://build.chromium.org/buildbot/continuous/LATEST/ 
and try it to see if the problem is resolved.
Status: Duplicate
Owner: j...@chromium.org
Mergedinto: 3811
Comment 38 by jarl.totland, Dec 04, 2008
I can confirm that the nightly build of 0.5.155.0 works fine for large textareas in 
twiki.
Comment 39 by marco.montel, Dec 04, 2008
Build 0.5.155.0 works for me in dokuwiki.
Comment 40 by lauri.turjansalo, Dec 12, 2008
I still have the same prob on phpBB forums. Using Chrome 1.0.
Comment 41 by nearaz, Dec 12, 2008
Still happens on phpBB forums (forum.unity3d.com, the posting message text area). 
Chrome 1.0.154.36.
Comment 42 by saul.rennison, Dec 12, 2008
Works fine in latest build
Comment 43 by frederik.claes, Dec 13, 2008
I'm using Google Chrome 0.4.154.33 and still suffer from this problem on various 
phpbb forums.
Comment 44 by frederik.claes, Dec 13, 2008
But I can report that Chromium 1.0.155.0 (6968) doesn't suffer from this bug.
Comment 45 by pverevkin, Dec 15, 2008
Happens on multiple sites with multiline text box:
Chrome 1.0.154.36
Windows XP SP3
Workaround: minimizing and maximizing Chrome window.

Please release the fix ASAP as it is extremely annoying.
Comment 46 by mixsynth, Dec 18, 2008
Update: this bug also applies to (at least some) center-justified <input> elements. 
Go to www.surfthechannel.com and type some text into the 'search' box at the top; it 
doesn't display properly until you click outside the box. (Still on Chrome 
1.0.154.36.)

@ #34: I can't refer you to the exact forum I'm looking at because it's members only. 
It seems apparent from the above comments that all phpBB installations are equally 
affected.
Comment 47 by jon@chromium.org, Dec 23, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Labels: Regression stable
Comment 48 by jon@chromium.org, Dec 23, 2008
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Labels: -Regression -stable
Comment 49 by mixsynth, Dec 29, 2008
Update: this bug also applies to some conventional left-justified <input> elements.

Example:
1) Go to www.youtube.com.
2) Type something into the main "search" box at the top.
3) Click anywhere in the middle of the text you just entered and try typing some 
more.
4) The text you insert overwrites the text already in the box until you click outside 
the box or scroll the page up or down.

Still using Chrome 1.0.154.36 on Vista Home Premium.
Comment 50 by mixsynth, Dec 30, 2008
Update: I can confirm that this bug is FIXED in the latest nightly builds of 
Chromium, so should be fixed in the next Chrome update. I'm currently running 
Chromium 1.0.156.0 (7477).
Comment 51 by lukas.zapletal, Jan 07, 2009
Great, thanks.
Comment 52 by reynardktli, Jan 16, 2009
Hi mixsynth :), just want to ask where did you get 1.0.156 from??

i just downloaded and installed chrome and still getting this problem.
the version of chrome is 1.0.154.43, and chrome's telling me my version is up to 
date.
Comment 54 by hirsch.will, Jan 16, 2009
reynardktli: nightly builds such as 1.0.156 are unstable intermediate builds not 
publicly released. You can download one from 
http://build.chromium.org/buildbot/snapshots/chromium-rel-xp/

For unstable builds with a bit more QA, switch to the dev channel, currently at 
2.0.157.0, at http://dev.chromium.org/getting-involved/dev-channel - the bug remains 
fixed in the current dev build.
Comment 55 by oracle2b, Feb 19, 2009
i'm using chrome build 1.0.154.48 and this bug still exists on surfthechannel.com 
search field.
Comment 56 by jon@chromium.org, Feb 19, 2009
This bug will be fixed in 2.x releases.  The fix is not being ported back to 1.x.  
Don't fear, we are not going to take a year to go from 1.x to 2.x.  If you want the 
fix now you should switch to the dev channel.
Comment 57 by vitmalina, Jul 16, 2009
I have a similar issue with a text input control. The control still have a focus, but
when you type, nothing is entered. If I click the left mouse button on it and hold it
and then type, it enters the text.

Also, the control has the yellow border arround it, which indicates it has a focus.
Comment 58 by progame, Jul 16, 2009
@vitmalina
this issue was fixed a long time ago

please open a new issue and include the problematic URL or (preferably) if possible 
upload a reduced case
Sign in to add a comment