My favorites | Sign in
Project Home Downloads Issues
New issue   Search
for
  Advanced search   Search tips
Issue 18756: StageFright - setLooping(true) leaves a noticeable gap in audio
767 people starred this issue.
Comments by non-members will not trigger notification emails to users who starred this issue.
Back to list
Status:  FutureRelease
Owner:  ----
Closed:  Jan 26


Sign in to add a comment
 
Reported by csyper...@gmail.com, Jul 23, 2011
NOTE: This form is only for reporting bugs found in the Android system
while developing Android applications. Use the Tools templates for issues
with the developer tools.

Please describe the problem in detail. Be sure to include:
- Steps to reproduce the problem (including sample code if appropriate).
- What happened.
- What you think the correct behavior should be.

I believe this is related to the new media framework stagefright where looped audio is not longer seemless.  Using the following code:

Media Player mediaPlayer = MediaPlayer.create(this, Uri.parse(someValidPath));
mediaPlayer.setLooping(true);

In my testing someValidPath points to a local file stored on a SD card.  

The audio will loop but there is a brief noticeable gap that didn't exist in previous versions of Android.  I have tested with various ogg and wav files and they all produce the same result a brief pause between sounds.  

Don't forget to mention which version of Android you're using, and/or which
device the problem appears on (model and Android version).

I have tested on Android 3.2 and have experienced the issue
kernel: 2.6.36-gb899528
android-build@apa28 #1
on the Motorola Xoom

On version 3.1 on the Xoom this problem was not present.

I feel that the expected output should be the same as it was in previous versions of Android where sample is looped seemlessly without any pause that is noticeable to the human ear.  

Please also run "adb bugreport" and archive the output.

attached is the output of adb bugreport as well as a sample file to illustrate the issue.




bugreport.txt
1005 KB   View   Download
whitenoise1.ogg
20.2 KB   Download
Comment 1 by newb...@gmail.com, Sep 12, 2011
i'm seeing the same thing on a Xoom (3.2) and a Droid X2 (2.3.3) ... however my n1 (2.3.3) and Droid X (2.3.3) still play looped audio correctly.

perhaps it has something to do with dual-core devices?
Comment 2 by coda.tri...@gmail.com, Sep 25, 2011
This bug is occurring for me on Droid 3 (2.3.4, dual-core) and not Droid 1 (2.2), both are using stagefright.
Comment 3 by GinaMC...@gmail.com, Oct 4, 2011
Bug started when Droid 2 Global upgraded to 2.3.3 in September. 
Comment 4 by aaronfo...@gmail.com, Oct 21, 2011
This bug effects under Droid bionic.
Comment 5 by firegirl...@gmail.com, Oct 22, 2011
My Droid 2 Global is also showing this issue. 
Comment 6 by csyper...@gmail.com, Oct 23, 2011
This is a Motorola specific issue.  I have spoken with someone at Motorola and I have gotten the impression that is isn't important enough for them to fix :(  If you think differently I would recommend letting them know on Twitter @motodev, ask them to fix the setLooping function.

Here is the MotoDev forum discussion I had with someone at Motorola, you may need a login to view.  

http://community.developer.motorola.com/t5/Android-App-Development-for/Issue-on-Moto-hardware-with-MediaPlayer-gt-setLooping-true/m-p/18837/highlight/false#M4024
Comment 7 by coda.tri...@gmail.com, Oct 23, 2011
Peter seems to be under the impression that this only affects short samples intended to be played as a tone; hopefully the developers are aware this obviously affects any kind of looping music, e.g. for games.
Comment 8 by denniso2...@gmail.com, Oct 24, 2011
This skipping is causing my Droid 2 Global to be unusable for many apps.  this is important  
denniso2323@gmail.com
Comment 9 by denniso2...@gmail.com, Oct 24, 2011
This skipping is causing my Droid 2 Global to be unusable for many apps.  this is important  
denniso2323@gmail.com
Comment 10 by labtech1...@yahoo.com, Nov 9, 2011
This problem is occurring on my Motorala Droid 2 Global. It has totally ruined the apps "Lightening Bug" and "Sleep and Relax" on my phone.  The problem began with the upgrade we received the other day.  Please fix the setLooping function.  Very important to me.

Comment 11 by csyper...@gmail.com, Nov 24, 2011
I have gotten reports that the problem is also present on Motorola's new Razr?  Has anyone seen this issue on non-motorola hardware?
Comment 12 by rob.land...@gmail.com, Dec 20, 2011
Happens on the Motorola Atrix as well, for looping apps such as "Relax and Sleep." 
Comment 13 by newb...@gmail.com, Dec 20, 2011
i'm seeing this behavior on a galaxy nexus (made by samsung) ... but i understand that ICS no longer uses StageFright? in fact, i'm now seeing this happen in the ICS emulator as well.


Comment 14 by csyper...@gmail.com, Dec 20, 2011
The problem is also present with Sleepy Time on all recent Motorola hardware.  
Comment 15 by csyper...@gmail.com, Dec 21, 2011
I have included a link to a very simple eclipse project that you can use to test for the setLooping bug.  This bug doesn’t seamlessly loop an audio file.  It plays a simple sine wave that can be used to easily detect if your device is displaying the bug.  I have also provided the direct like to the apk file as well.  
 
I feel this bug is an important bug to get fixed.  Although this is a simple example, it has real world problems including:

*Looped music playback
*Sound machine type applications
*Game sample loops


I feel this bug hurts the Android platform and encourages the ‘fragmentation’ fault argument.  Some devices/firmware don’t present the bug while others do.  For example, almost every recent Motorola device has the bug, but most HTC devices don’t.  The Xoom shipped without the bug, but a firmware update introduced the bug (I don’t know which version introduced it).  

I have an application, SleepyTime, which used to be available on all devices but now isn’t available on many devices on the Android Market because the bug is present on those devices.  This creates a bad user experience for the user because:

*A user on phone A can get the app, but a user on phone B may not be able to.  
*A user with phone X paid for the app, then upgrades to phone Z, which can’t get the app because this device has the bug, and now doesn’t understand why they can’t download the application they paid for.  

To anyone experiencing this bug, please run this application on any device you have access to and report the Android version, kernel, device name, and weather the bug is present.  We need to give the engineers as much information as possible if we want this to get resolved.  Please get as many people as possible to start this bug to give it more visibility.  

Eclipse Project:
http://cwssoft.com/downloads/LoopBug.zip

APK:
http://cwssoft.com/downloads/LoopBug.apk



Here are my test results:  


========================================
HTC G2
Android Version:   
2.3.4

Kernel:
2.6.35.10-g96de068

Status: 
Pass

========================================
Motorla Xoom
Android Version: 
3.2.1

Kernel:
2.6.36.3-g111d827

Status:
FAIL!!!!

========================================

HTC Nexus One
Android Version:
2.3.6

Kernel:
2.6.35.7-59465-g42bad32

Status: 
Pass

========================================

Kindle Fire 

Android Version:
N/A

Kernel:
N/A

Status:
Pass

========================================

Logitech Revue

Android Version:
3.1

Kernel:
N/A

Status:
Fail!!!


Chuck Syperski
CWS Software LLC
Comment 16 by csyper...@gmail.com, Dec 21, 2011
Sorry, I have also gotten reports that the Galaxy Nexus suffers from this bug as well.  
Comment 17 by Duality....@gmail.com, Dec 21, 2011
I'm experiencing this too on my Samsung Galaxy Nexus. Running 4.0.1 (updates are handled by Telstra bleh hence the version. PLEASE fix this, it makes any sleep/ambient app useless.
Comment 18 by newb...@gmail.com, Dec 22, 2011
I'm the developer of Lightning Bug, an ambiance app similar to SleepyTime. I've been following this bug report since it was originally filed. It's now confirmed in *3 major versions* of Android and we still haven't seen a official fix or even a written acknowledgment from the Android team! 

First, I'd like to say thanks to Chuck of SleepyTime for filing the report and his continued input.

Second, I'd like to confirm that I've seen exactly the same results in my testing. The Gingerbread issue seemed only to effect dual-core devices, and therefore wasn't present in the emulator. ICS seems a bit different though, as I see the issue in the ICS emulator too.

Third, I'd like to add that we actually built our own NDK interface to opensles that more or less fixed the problem in Gingerbread and Honeycomb. But this fix only works when our app is in focus. When the app goes to the background and the user, say, scrolls through his gmail inbox, the audio experiences obvious distortion, even though we've set the stream priority to Music.

And this fix, most unfortunately, doesn't work in ICS!

We're now looking at writing a complete audio component using the NDK that handles its own streaming to buffer ... an understandably frustrating endeavor when we'd *much* rather focus on updating our UI and delivering the more visible features our users have been asking for.

I realize this is not a forum for complaints ... but I got nothing back from the Android developer group. For such a seemingly simple issue? This is low hanging fruit is it not? I'd tell my users it was "Google's Fault", but would they even believe me over something so simple?

So I'm begging ... please ... could someone from the Android team at least acknowledge the issue?

Thanks,
Chris Newby
lightningbug.me



Comment 19 by lindaparriott, Dec 23, 2011
Lightning Bug doesn't work on ICS 4.0.2. If an OS bug is at the root of this, I hope the Android team will address this soon.
Comment 20 by jonbelf...@gmail.com, Dec 24, 2011
This sucks, use looping apps to fall asleep every night and now they don't even work on Ice Cream Sandwich. Well my iPod does it great, guess I'll go for iPhone next time.
Comment 21 by porter.a...@gmail.com, Dec 25, 2011
Samsung galaxy nexus here. Same issue, I've had to keep my droid 1 around to get some rest  
Comment 22 by natasha....@hotmail.com, Dec 27, 2011
Skipping on Samsung Infuse, gingerbread. Seriously annoyed that I bought so many plug-Ins for them not to work with my phone. This is why I quit blackberry. 
Comment 23 by Saturnin...@gmail.com, Dec 27, 2011
nexus... upgraded from the original droid and can't believe I have to use my old phone for lighteningbug.  This sucks!
Comment 24 by choec...@gmail.com, Dec 27, 2011
Some apps (e.g., "White Noise") seem to work fine on ICS (Galaxy Nexus). Is there a trick or API call they're using that these other apps aren't? I assume they're looping as well?
Comment 25 by jko...@gmail.com, Dec 27, 2011
This appears to be a pretty big issue making several top apps basically unusable.  I must admit that I am stunned this hasn't been acknowledged and more importantly addressed by Google yet.
Comment 26 by newb...@gmail.com, Dec 27, 2011
A note on White Noise ... First, I think its a great app that has a lot of very happy users. However, from what I can tell its using a custom or 3-party codec to play AIF files. AIFs are uncompressed though ... meaning they require at least 10x more storage space than mp3 or ogg\vorbis. In addition, White Noise is using relatively short audio samples compared to other apps and doesn't allow mixing multiple samples simultaneously.

This is to say that while it appears White Noise is not affected by the looping issue in the standard Android SDK media player, it does so at a cost in features.
Comment 27 by momto...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
I am having these issues on my Droid Incredible. Pleases
Fix soon! 
Comment 28 by D.Wolff....@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Droid 2 user with skipping audio. Help! 
Comment 29 by frank.va...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Currently using a Galaxy S running droid Gingerbread (2.3.3)

Skipping is less after update by developer, but only if app is active on screen. if I start a different app, of even blackout the screen, the skipping returns.
Comment 30 by cur...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Effects Google Nexus S since the update to 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich.
Comment 31 by CMatheso...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Plz fix

Comment 32 by lisacwes...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Skips on galaxy nexus  
Comment 33 by lukemcnu...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Please fix....
Comment 34 by goodtimi...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Xoom 3.2  seamless loops please.
Comment 35 by anexb...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Important app. Please fix ASAP

Comment 36 by mija...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
PleaPlease fix, Google!
Comment 37 by shenan...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Please fix lighting bug application
Comment 38 by cfwaa...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Please fix the lightning bug app
Comment 39 by gillesfo...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
It happens anytime I open an app or pull down my notification bar. i have HTC Droid incredible to. And I'm using lightening bug. It's similiar to the whitenoise app. Love it, just hate the skips amd gaps. 
Comment 40 by xKatiexL...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
I've noticed the audio gap as well. Please fix it!
Comment 41 by frischfr...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Audio gaps for the DROID. Please fix
Comment 42 by fritz...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
lightning bug issue here as well
android 2.3.6
samsung charge SCH-I510
hardware version i510.06
this is a single core system btw
Comment 44 by imafos...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Droid RAZR. Audio gaps on looped audio. Also when accessing other programs, the audio in the background is very choppy.
Comment 45 by hkrawi...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
I have a charge as well.  as long as i stay in the lightning bug app it is fine...the moment i have it in the background it skips.  hoping for a fix soon.
Comment 46 by Owe...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Gaps in video every time lightning bug is launched.  Fix please ASAP.
Comment 47 by mzglo...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Hi. I have an HTC EVO 4G gingerbread and I'm having the same problem whereas I didn't before. Please fix I Love my lighting bug. Thanx :0)
Comment 48 by Mateo...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Audio gapssssssss!!!!!!!!! 
Comment 49 by dan.stei...@gmail.com, Dec 28, 2011
Audio gaps!!!!!
Comment 50 by xx.bette...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Samsung Galaxy S (I)
Android version: 2.3.5
Status: Fail
Definitely has audio gaps. I love this app, especially because of the ability to customize the screensaver clock thing. That's what stood out to me. I had to still using the app because the audio gaps make it difficult to sleep. (I use campfire and rain.)
PLEASE fix the audio gaps...
Comment 51 by mbarness...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Having issues with Lighning Bug on the Galaxy Nexus  as well. A fix would be greatly appreciated Google.
Comment 52 by brian.du...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Having issues with audio gap on my Droid 2 and my Razr. 
Comment 53 by johntrav...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Having audio gap issue on Galaxy Nexus as well. Android version 4.0.2.
Comment 54 by gargu...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Please fix google 
Comment 55 by robchris...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
To all the people posting useless "me too" or app-specific comments, please star this issue instead of posting comments unless your comments add helpful information not already included in the OP or previous comments. Thanks.
Comment 56 by ahuitt69, Dec 29, 2011
There are gaps  in the loop when playing, it did not happen previously. 
Comment 57 by scottish...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
HTC sensation. Intermittent gaps in sound not any pattern I can discern just happens
Comment 58 by jackylon...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Audio lags when Lightning Bug is in the background and I write a text.
HTC Bravo with s-off & Cyanogenmod 7.0.3
Comment 59 by macwi...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
There is a sizeable gap in the audio to the point where I've thought the app quit. Please fix! I listen to this every night to get to sleep
Comment 60 by lollie...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
HTC Droid Incredible 2... Noticeable distortion (gapping) when Lightning Bug running in background. 
Comment 61 by jlpadov...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Same issue in my Samsung Galaxy SII. 
Comment 62 by camptont...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
LG esteem also experiences this frustrating sound gap. Resolve immediately please. 
Comment 63 by speedsh...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Audio gaps!!!!!! On galaxy s epic 4g

Comment 64 by AnneKirs...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Having issue with gaps using lightningbug on first gen droid. Please fix
Comment 65 by dkampha...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
The sound gaps need to be remedied since android is your biggest market. 
DK
Comment 66 by dcasca...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Please fix this shipping sound on my Samsung galaxy s
Comment 67 by spanking...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Sound skips ever since I updated my Samsung Galaxy.
Comment 68 by seanpmcc...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
If its causing problems, hope it gets fixed soon.
Comment 69 by DionAppl...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Please fix this issue.
Comment 70 by bukkakec...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Sprint evo, android 2.3.3, skips and glitchy, I use this app every day. Google, pls acknowledge this issue, pls implement a bug fix!
Comment 71 by joediaz...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Fix it please.
Comment 72 by salut...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Skip in the Galaxy Nexus pls fix!
Comment 73 by Baltimor...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Droid bionic user. Had this issue since Se
ptember 2011. Please fix.
Comment 74 by RTCook...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Skipping on Droid Bionic 
Comment 75 by ltrencon...@gmail.com, Dec 29, 2011
Horrible skipping on the Motorola Photon 4G!
Comment 76 by boisep...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Audio gaps
Comment 77 by vlgo...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
the gaps are very annoying
Comment 78 by rrhodes...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Galaxy nexus running ice cream does constantly skip...please fix this!.
Comment 79 by jackafer...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Skipping on Nexus running ice cream...as others say its annoying

Comment 80 by barry72b...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Plz fix issues
Comment 81 by mdlandsv...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
I am experiencing gaps in audio too.
Comment 82 by javasmoo...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Samsung galaxy. skips several times very irritating
Comment 83 by dnbdr...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Samsung Google nexus has gap when using lightening bug with new os download. Please fix.
Comment 84 by apg5...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
I only experience the gap for a split second as I lock the phone or when I place it on the nightstand.  While it is not a huge bother, it would be nice to have it fixed. SRunning on HTC Sense. Love this App by the way!!!
Comment 85 by them...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
the duration of this bug and the lack of effort in fixing it is precisely the type of thing that makes people consider dumping andriod for an iPhone
Comment 86 by kdorw...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Samsung Fascinate, also. Please fix!
Comment 87 by Shadowca...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Serious skipping with my Droid Bionic.   Please fix soon 
Comment 88 by mistydba...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
Please fix ASAP

Comment 89 by glock3...@gmail.com, Dec 30, 2011
I have the same gap in audio looping on both my and my wife's Motorola DROIDX2. 2.3 ... it is a irritating problem and Google should help the developer to fix the issue... after all us( the consumer ). And the developer's are what pays Google's salary's ... Google should be more consumer concise.. and take better care of us
Comment 90 by marc.rea...@gmail.com, Dec 31, 2011
Wonderful concept  Help then Thanks
Comment 92 by flurbygu...@gmail.com, Dec 31, 2011
Having same problem on HTC Incredible - please fix this.
Comment 93 by shaun.go...@gmail.com, Dec 31, 2011
plz fix, thx.
Comment 94 by Josh.Dix...@gmail.com, Dec 31, 2011
These are the kind of issues apple iPhones don't have. This is the reason ill be switching over and banning Motorola from my personal list of reliable companies. Anyone else annoyed with this should do the same. I'm so bummed I got my droid razor in the first place now...
Comment 95 by neilld...@gmail.com, Dec 31, 2011
Please help them get this fixed!

Comment 96 by ricde...@yahoo.com, Dec 31, 2011
Its also happening to my Samsung Tra
nsformer. From Boost. I really like lighting bug. But its really 
Getting announing
Comment 97 by chicc...@gmail.com, Dec 31, 2011
Plz fix! Android 2.2 HTC wildfire. It always worked fine :(
Comment 98 by thebeamr...@gmail.com, Dec 31, 2011
Fix quick please

Comment 99 by justama...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
Please fix lag issue very annoying. You can do it...
Comment 100 by mikey...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
Seeing issue on droid bionic. Please address this. 
Comment 101 by rjdpe...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
Please fix ; very annoying. I just got samsung galaxy nexus what i would expect to be able to handle something as easy as this since it is a google phone. Please fix
Comment 102 by Cain.Edm...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
I have yet to have any issues with my galaxy s vibrant however It is an older phone.  I also haven't seen any trouble with the gateway android honeycomb  3.1 but have only used it twice on the tablet.
Comment 103 by k9weezer...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
PLEASE FIX THIS ISSUE. MY 4 YO SON GOES TO SLEEP BY THIS APP EVERY NIGHT. THE BUG IS DISRUPTIVE. 
Comment 104 by MikeLewi...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
Needs to be fixed very irritating.  I have purchased add ons to this app, wasted mobey at this time
Comment 105 by capnki...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
Also present with our Droid X2 from the beginning, and my Droid X after update to v. 2.3.3. Pls repair ASAP!
Comment 106 by 1angel.j...@gmail.com, Jan 1, 2012
Please address ASAP. LIGHTNINGBUG is a fantastic app that I used nightly with my Ally and it looped seamlessly. Now with my **Droid X2 it skips so bad I cannot utilize the app anymore**.My fingers are crossed that Google will take the necessary steps to correct their bug so I can resume enjoying my favorite sleep aide.
Comment 107 by GoldenEa...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
Please just fix it.

Comment 108 by wbw...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
HTC EVO 3D
Fix this loop gap please. It is irritating.
Comment 109 by azzo...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
Come on Google. It's what you DON'T do that matters just as much as what you do! It does no good for consumers to pay these ridiculous dollar amounts for these 'smart' phones that are capable of and SUPPOSED to do so much! The people and companies that are supposed to be staying on top of things and doing THEIR job to ensure and backup the quality of performance that we  are paying for are losing more respect than maybe you realize. If you even care. So many apps and services are such horrible failures when it comes to supporting the android phones that we consumers continue to CONSTANTLY feel that we will never get our money's worth out of what we pay for these phones. So maybe we are the ones that need to step back and reevaluate why we are continuing to allow you guys to rob us blind of what we CHOOSE to spend our money on and hit you in YOUR pocket and maybe we will see a change in how valuable you think our concerns and issues are about the things we no longer waste OUR money on that you chose to not give your attention to. The most important thing these companies like Google, Samsung, HTC, Verizon, etc need to put first and foremost in their priorities is accepting the truth that BEFORE it is their money, it is OUR money that we chose to spend on promising products and services that they all refuse to live up to. There are ALWAYS other options! Get these empty promises filled before you have noone to make promises to.  As it stands, the vast majority of us feel that we always just end up with crazy-expensive phones built to be capable of performing so many tasks so well, but in the end just as always have an overpriced phone that still barely makes many calls without dropping or losing signal; missed texts or even sent to wrong person due to malfunctioning expensive over-priced phone, that needs to be recharged 3+ times per day and erratic rebooting due to too much usage of these fine $500+- toy phones. Unbelievable.  Samsung Charge on Verizon ICS
Comment 110 by j...@divasdoggydaycare.com, Jan 2, 2012
Droid Incredible 2 reporting issues.
Comment 111 by zhash...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
Samsung skyrocket experiencing problems too! 
Comment 112 by lyobov...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
I have this on Droid X.
Comment 113 by mpori...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
This bug needs to be addressed asap
Comment 114 by mpori...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
This bug needs to be addressed asap
Comment 115 by wmar4...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
I am having this issue with my HTC Evo design.
Comment 116 by aflselt...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
I have an LG Ally which is displaying the same issue.
Comment 117 by elizabet...@gmail.com, Jan 2, 2012
I have an HTC evo 3d, I don't have the problem, but it does need to be addressed for others who are.
Comment 118 by kayalb...@gmail.com, Jan 3, 2012
I have this problem on my droid global 2
Comment 119 by d5m...@gmail.com, Jan 3, 2012
Epic 4G - Reporting Issue... Please Fix!!!!
Comment 120 by GrantBru...@gmail.com, Jan 3, 2012
Galaxy S 4G. Please fix.
Comment 121 by THEHCGCo...@gmail.com, Jan 3, 2012
Plz repair. Android Incredible. Thx! 
Comment 122 by Saturnin...@gmail.com, Jan 3, 2012
criticle app for me.  plz fix
Comment 123 by bethbana...@gmail.com, Jan 4, 2012
Please fix. I have Droid razr
Comment 124 by suicidal...@gmail.com, Jan 4, 2012
Having issues with Lighning Bug on the htc evo 4g as well. A fix would be greatly appreciated Google.
Comment 125 by Fernando...@gmail.com, Jan 4, 2012
I have a EVO 3 d, hope you fix the problem soon Google.


Comment 126 by james.je...@gmail.com, Jan 4, 2012
Samsung galaxy tab 
Comment 127 by envyminn...@gmail.com, Jan 4, 2012
HTC MyTouch Slide 4G, please fix
Comment 128 by wyllyn...@gmail.com, Jan 5, 2012
please fix. i have a droid x.
Comment 129 by thorough...@gmail.com, Jan 5, 2012
Please fix this. I will not update my phone until this is fixed so that I can continue to use the lightningbug app.
Comment 130 by Stormysk...@gmail.com, Jan 5, 2012
Skipping on my Samsung Galaxy II Epic Touch. Love Lightning Bug and its now unusable. Please address this problem with our platform developers! You're hurting apps for Android! 
Comment 131 by lacey.lo...@gmail.com, Jan 5, 2012
I just got the nexus prime and now I can no longer enjoy lighting bug. It skipps and freezes. It worked great on my droid incredable. Please fix these problems so I can drown out my noisy neighbors!
Comment 132 by Pauly...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Gnexus here. Have the same problem with other similar programs 
Comment 133 by LoBu...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Please fix this issue ASAP!
Comment 134 by baldovin...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Pls.fix this action
Comment 135 by d...@lawson-online.co.uk, Jan 6, 2012
Please fix this. 

Comment 136 by pastorlo...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Yes please fix this
Comment 137 by mleh...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Please fix this.
Comment 138 by Steven.F...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Please fix
Comment 139 by lilijone...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Please fix
Comment 140 by julie.z...@gmail.com, Jan 6, 2012
Galaxy X. Same problem.
Comment 141 by DCurtis...@gmail.com, Jan 7, 2012
Please Google, fix this issue!  I'm having the same problems on my Galaxy Nexus!
Comment 142 by themajor...@gmail.com, Jan 7, 2012
Samsung exhibit. Pls fix.
Comment 143 by k...@thinksoft.ca, Jan 7, 2012
This bug still exists on Galaxy NEXUS.  Please fix.  thx
Comment 144 by Jeanette...@gmail.com, Jan 7, 2012
HTC Wildfire. No problems.
Comment 145 by ncmatth...@gmail.com, Jan 7, 2012
Major irritation for Sleepytime app running on Samsung Droid Charge with gingerbread. Just started occurring in the last few days. This new skipping probl
em is making this excellent app useless.
Comment 146 by lindsa...@gmail.com, Jan 7, 2012
Its like listening to a scratched CD. Not cool....
Comment 147 by suzannen...@gmail.com, Jan 7, 2012
There its definitely a gap in the loops and google needs to fix this!
Comment 148 by stl1...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
Yes...I hear it as well!!
Comment 149 by drtone...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
I am having the same problem with my droid  bionic please fix immediately
Comment 150 by mgps1...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
Intermittent drops in audio. Htc Amaze ....
Comment 151 by pharmac...@dvortex.net, Jan 8, 2012
Droid X ... Me too
Comment 152 by bhear...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
Me to it is aweful
Comment 153 by ghensley...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
Please fix. 
Comment 155 by amir.n...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
THIS SHOULD BE FIXED ASAP
Comment 156 by robertde...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
This should be addressed by google asap to ensure customer satisfaction. 
Comment 157 by squaredh...@gmail.com, Jan 8, 2012
I am having the same issue...every five to six seconds...I get a pause.
Comment 158 by Jasoncp2...@gmail.com, Jan 9, 2012
It seems all looping type media on my samsung nexus is causing this skip/delay.  I did not experience this on older droid operating system
Comment 159 by Russ...@gmail.com, Jan 9, 2012
Does not work with ICS. Fix asap please.
Comment 161 by anniev...@gmail.com, Jan 9, 2012
DROID2
ANDROID 2.3.3
Love this app, please assist developer.
Thank you.
Comment 162 by HeatherC...@gmail.com, Jan 9, 2012
Please fix the lightning bug app
Comment 163 by PrsnalT...@gmail.com, Jan 9, 2012
Fix the lightning bug app please!
Comment 166 by ana.deni...@gmail.com, Jan 10, 2012
Google....Android developer team... are you there?
Im experiencing this issue as well, thought I was going crazy hearing things
Mytouch 4g gingerbread
Comment 167 by sendit2b...@gmail.com, Jan 10, 2012
Motorola Atrix 2 also having problems. I absolutely relied on white noise apps before I bought this phone. Upgraded from a Samsung Captivate to this brand new Motorola... I had no idea I was buying a phone that could not perform one of the most basic and important functions I need from it.

... very disappointed. This is a hard-core Google fan that's seriously considering switching to Apple phones.
Comment 168 by Irishpap...@gmail.com, Jan 10, 2012
Please..... PLEASE fix this bug. This will drive the Pope to drink.
Comment 169 by xxgothim...@gmail.com, Jan 10, 2012
Samsung Galaxy S...Google, please fix the lag in the lightnin bug app!
Comment 170 by ctk...@gmail.com, Jan 10, 2012
I hear bug with White Noise app running on Galaxy Nexus/ICS. Please fix!
Comment 171 by lynn.gra...@gmail.com, Jan 10, 2012
Lots of gaps in audio. Hope this doesn't cause problems with alarm!
Comment 172 by skor...@yahoo.com, Jan 10, 2012
This really needs to. Be addressed as it is a problem.For a great many people who rely on. Your service and expect it to be reliable as always.
Comment 173 by skor...@yahoo.com, Jan 10, 2012
Please fix
Comment 174 by Batman11...@gmail.com, Jan 10, 2012
Fix it Google.! I need this.!
Comment 175 by megaprop...@gmail.com, Jan 11, 2012
 android please fix the bug 
Comment 176 by willowsm...@gmail.com, Jan 11, 2012
I am experiencing the same issuea with my epic.
Comment 177 by paschen...@gmail.com, Jan 11, 2012
This being an issue with the samsung nexus I'll be hanging on to my fascinate till this problem is fixed.  Come on andriod... show those apple devs you actually listen to your users 
Comment 178 by lynderan...@gmail.com, Jan 12, 2012
I love lightning bug, however the audio skips now more than ever when I play my plug in content :-( please fix, I paid for this app...
Comment 179 by CamiloSa...@gmail.com, Jan 13, 2012
asus eepad tranformer prime tf201 - affectedl
Comment 180 by pwilkese...@gmail.com, Jan 13, 2012
I agree with many of the above comments. This really sucks! 
Comment 181 by david.gr...@gmail.com, Jan 13, 2012
I need my sleep when traveling.  Please prioritize! 
Comment 182 by dpast...@gmail.com, Jan 13, 2012
My motorola Droid does not like this bug. 
Comment 184 by percola...@gmail.com, Jan 13, 2012
I have same problem with lightening bug sound skipping and gaps in the sound.  I'm using HTC incredible its so annoying I'm thinking of switching to an iPhone and saying f u Google!
Comment 185 by gillian....@gmail.com, Jan 14, 2012
Please address this issue! 
Samsung galaxy user
Comment 186 by treborg...@gmail.com, Jan 14, 2012
Please fix as soon as possible. HTC Rezound.
Comment 187 by rexster...@gmail.com, Jan 15, 2012
I have the same problem on my ice cream sandwich motorola zoom skipping

Comment 188 by NateThom...@gmail.com, Jan 15, 2012
Same problem evo 4g ics deck 
Comment 189 by mbmyers1...@gmail.com, Jan 15, 2012
I love my lightning bug,  but the audio gets funky!  Please help.  I have an HTC Evo 4G. 
Comment 190 by llew...@gmail.com, Jan 15, 2012
Please fix, i need sleep! 
Comment 191 by emilygan...@gmail.com, Jan 16, 2012
Same problem here. And I need to sleep... Working graveyard shift and all.  How has this issue NOT been fixed yet? Or better yet, why haven't I switched to more stable OS's like, say, Apple? 
Comment 192 by danielle...@yahoo.com, Jan 16, 2012
Please fix
Comment 193 by jover...@gmail.com, Jan 17, 2012
Please address this bug/issue dear Android


Comment 194 by leahinth...@gmail.com, Jan 17, 2012
One of my fav apps... please fix problem so I can use it again..... the skips are pretty bad and very noticeable.
Samsung Stratosphere
Comment 195 by TheTrave...@gmail.com, Jan 17, 2012
Yes I to get a gap. I need a steady sound to sleep by.

Comment 196 by Menne...@gmail.com, Jan 17, 2012
Plz fix
Comment 197 by kkinsma...@gmail.com, Jan 17, 2012
Same problem here..driving me nuts!
Comment 198 by katcop...@gmail.com, Jan 18, 2012
Android version 4.0.3 which  had just received the update last night, has that noticeable bug in it. I requested money back on something I purchased thinking it was that, and it wasn't, it was this android update.  Please fix, I would hate to put the older version back on, as I like the liiks of this newer one.  Thank you, snowkat50
Comment 199 by dway...@gmail.com, Jan 18, 2012
Fix please!
Comment 200 by scotty...@gmail.com, Jan 18, 2012
Please fix this....

LG g2x through T-Mobile. 
Comment 201 by Sirus...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
Fix please. 
Galaxy Nexus Verizon
Comment 202 by BassRock...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
While I'm not experiencing problems with my current phone, I plan to upgrade soon & am concerned my new phone will have this problem. Please fix it A.S.A.P. . Thank you
Comment 203 by BassRock...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
While I'm not experiencing problems with my current phone, I plan to upgrade soon & am concerned my new phone will have this problem. Please fix it A.S.A.P. . Thank you
Comment 204 by Rjay1965...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
Please need some sleep

Comment 205 by afp0...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
Please fix this issue.
Comment 206 by csmith...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
HTC Merge ...please fix 

Comment 207 by antisw...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
Ridiculous! And Google expects Android to take over iOS? Dream On. 
Google can't even keep the OS stable. New update breaks the previous functions! What is this?! At least don't touch what's already working fine. Damn! 

Comment 208 by antisw...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
Is there a work around with this? I'm thinking to run 2 media players. Has anyone try that? 

This bug reminds me to Linux. When Linux was born, people loved it and hated Windows. They predicted Linux will capture 50% of market in 2010. Wrong!
Until when there were too many Linux versions, people started to realized it's difficult to keep track and to get support. Don't get me wrong, Linux is great.
Now people back to closed OS like Windows 7 and Lion OS. It's because there is no standard in Linux. Everybody want to create their own "cool" things. 

And now with Android, if google doesn't fix this, it will end up like Linux.
Comment 209 by antisw...@gmail.com, Jan 19, 2012
This is really bad if no one seems to care to fix it. Even if they fixed it, it will take 1 year or more for most users to be updated.
And because of this! App Developers paid the price. If you see recent comments of relax and white noise apps, they got rating 1! The users complained there is a gap, thus it is useless app. Users blamed apps and developers for being stupid!
Android will never get the blame.

Comment 210 by busylau...@gmail.com, Jan 20, 2012
It's very irritating when a relaxation/white noise app has such a definite audio skip. Please address this issue. It is very noticeable on my Droid Bionic.
Comment 211 by rdevkot...@gmail.com, Jan 20, 2012
I recently brought motorola xoom (version 3.2). It is great tablet and i like it but when i play the videos (those transfered froom my pc) , audio of the video is slower and it does not match with the videos. This problem is occuring with almost all videos. I am wondering if its some kind of bug:(. Please help me out if there is any solution. Thank you:)

Comment 212 by debrabac...@gmail.com, Jan 20, 2012
Lightening Bug was the bomb sleep machine app until our Thrive took the Google update. PLEASE fix the skipping issues.
Comment 213 by wasserfe...@gmail.com, Jan 21, 2012
Please fix!
Comment 214 by wasserfe...@gmail.com, Jan 21, 2012
Please fix!
Comment 215 by PetalsRo...@gmail.com, Jan 22, 2012
My galaxy nexus has this bug. It has made it so i had to hunt for a used Droid just so i could sleep. I use lightning bug. Sleep now can't be used unless i leave the display on.
Chronic insomnia sucks! Imagine my dismay when i found out the fracking expnsive droid nexus couldn't run the best sleep assisting programs i NEED!
Comment 216 by mrkro...@gmail.com, Jan 22, 2012
Please, please, please fix this app! I love it!! I am using the Motorola Xoom 4.0.3 started skipping after the update 3 days ago. Some skip after 10 seconds and others after 24.
Comment 217 by cd23mur...@gmail.com, Jan 23, 2012
Please fix 
Comment 218 by krystal....@gmail.com, Jan 23, 2012
I am using the samsung sidekick 4g, and have the delay, however, I never hd the delay on the lg ally. Really wish you would fix it.
Comment 220 by naomijoy...@gmail.com, Jan 24, 2012
I have a Motorola , a Droid 2 and there is a very distrcting gap in the audio. It occurs with any of the audio clips and consistantly within a few minutes of activating the app.
Comment 221 by nielsen....@gmail.com, Jan 24, 2012
Several of my apps  that have longer sounds or use loops (especially Lightning Bug) are now useless.  I have a Samsung Galaxy ii Epic 4g Touch


Comment 222 by runner2...@gmail.com, Jan 25, 2012
Please fix this issue
Comment 223 by aaronlee...@gmail.com, Jan 25, 2012
Also a problem on Nexus S with ICS 4.0.3
Comment 224 by ylv...@gmail.com, Jan 25, 2012
Please follow up on gap audij issues.
Comment 225 by project member marc...@google.com, Jan 26, 2012
(No comment was entered for this change.)
Status: FutureRelease
Comment 226 by stimpy...@gmail.com, Jan 26, 2012
This sucks i thought having a new phone would make things better not woese im not impressed at all if this is how your product is then whats to say about the company ya think about that you corporite fuck holes. Take your penis and pogo stick your asses to the moon ... fix it dick wads
Comment 227 by robert.g...@gmail.com, Jan 26, 2012
Giant FAIL of the Android team, not even taking a look at this seemingly simple issue!
Samsung Galaxy Nexus, Android 4.0.2
Comment 228 by nielsen....@gmail.com, Jan 26, 2012
ooh!  They just updated the status.  THANK YOU Google!
Comment 229 by david.gr...@gmail.com, Jan 26, 2012
Don't thank them too soon.... it's taken a while for them to even respond.
Comment 230 by Alexei.R...@gmail.com, Jan 27, 2012
Afecting galaxy nexus
Comment 231 by krzyszto...@gmail.com, Jan 27, 2012
Galaxy Nexus 4.0.1/4.0.2 affected
Comment 232 by mattradb...@gmail.com, Jan 27, 2012
Droid 1seems affected as well.
Comment 233 by fsm...@gmail.com, Jan 28, 2012
Xoom as well. Unfortunately one of my favorite apps does not work BC of it
Comment 234 by zor...@gmail.com, Jan 28, 2012
I am also among the many who need this fixed. HTC sensation, ICS.
Comment 235 by AnneMeac...@gmail.com, Jan 28, 2012
Please fix this. I love my GNexus but this issue is very very frustrating.
Comment 236 by mando...@gmail.com, Jan 28, 2012
The audio gaps are very noticeable on my gingerbread run android. 
Comment 237 by gary.ku...@gmail.com, Jan 29, 2012
Bummer.  Several apps worked fine before ICS, but no longer on Xoom.

gary.kuyat@gmail.com

Comment 238 by joseph.e...@gmail.com, Jan 30, 2012
please work to resolve this gap issue.
Comment 239 by watsonvi...@gmail.com, Jan 30, 2012
Having the gap sucks . Xoom ics. Please fix. Seems to be a problems on sound sleep deluxe app also.
Comment 242 by jacquel...@gmail.com, Jan 30, 2012
LG marquee -lightening bug-gap is bad please re-open & address issue.

Comment 243 by ivonnedi...@gmail.com, Jan 31, 2012
GOOGLE...I AM REALLY DISAPPOINTED IN YOUR LACK OF CONCERN REGARDING THIS MATTER AND HOW IT AFFECTS THOSE THAT RELY ON YOU.PLEASE GET IT TOGETHER 
Comment 244 by attws...@gmail.com, Feb 1, 2012
App has an obvious gap in audio.  Why can't we resolve?

Comment 245 by brooks.a...@gmail.com, Feb 1, 2012
Audio gap 
Comment 246 by gabi.net...@gmail.com, Feb 1, 2012
Audio gap is still there. It's a bug, not a lighting bug.
Comment 247 by khaa...@gmail.com, Feb 1, 2012
Fix it!!
Comment 248 by muragur...@gmail.com, Feb 1, 2012
 This problem is occurring on my Motorala Droid 2Global. None of my noise apps "Lightening Bug" and "Sleep and Relax" are working on my phone. The problem began with the upgrade to Gingerbread.
Comment 249 by gregs...@gmail.com, Feb 1, 2012
Gaps on nexus s i9020t with ics 4.0.3 as well
Comment 250 by shiloh.a...@gmail.com, Feb 2, 2012
Same problem on Droid x. Google please fix! 
Comment 251 by riaanju...@gmail.com, Feb 2, 2012
Audio gaps makes my most used app unusable (Lightning Bug). I'm on Samsung Galaxy S2 with ICS 4.0.3, please fix!
Comment 252 by AntonSau...@gmail.com, Feb 2, 2012
Please fix this issue.  Samsung Galaxy S II

Comment 253 by becale...@gmail.com, Feb 3, 2012
I also have a Droid 2 Global and I used to love the Lightning Bug app!! It helps me fall asleep when I'm away from home, but this problem is killing me!! Please fix it ASAP!!!

Comment 254 by thesonne...@gmail.com, Feb 3, 2012
Fix it Google! This is happening to all apps that are like this. Can't sleep!
Comment 255 by Aj.Mille...@gmail.com, Feb 3, 2012
Well i purchased the google one despite it lacking a few key features (sd card reader) but i was putting my money on the fact that it would have a reasonably stable OS.  I have come to regret my decision would, no have, cautioned everyone i have met not to bother with the nexus one until some of these OS issues have been worked out.  in addition to a host of other problems, (camera crashing, apps failing to launch, doc reader failing time and time again) i find out now that it cant do something as simple as loop music files.  Really im pretty sure a gen one Iphone had that one figured out.  Please fix. 
Comment 256 by CMatheso...@gmail.com, Feb 3, 2012
So this is STILL an issue plz at least address the android community about it. It is very noticeable and quite sad we are not supported on new phones. Gnexus 4.0.3 

Comment 257 by radsh...@gmail.com, Feb 5, 2012
Affects my samsung captivate.
Comment 258 by Salinara...@gmail.com, Feb 5, 2012
I just bought a Droid razor and I used "relax and sleep" to help me sleep and it does not work as well now and it really frustrates me. For how much I spent on this phone, I want things to work proper. Please fix this issue ASAP. 
Comment 259 by 3dimod...@gmail.com, Feb 5, 2012
Please fix this issue. I can't go to sleep now! This worked beautifully before and now it is just plain annoying! 

Comment 260 by vorlonag...@gmail.com, Feb 6, 2012
I've seen audio stop entirely.  Ltng bug was running in background when I started typing this and it did not survive more than 2 to 4 keys. Acer Iconia A500
Comment 261 by vorlonag...@gmail.com, Feb 6, 2012
I've seen audio stop entirely.  Ltng bug was running in background when I started typing this and it did not survive more than 2 to 4 keys. Acer Iconia A500
Comment 262 by vorlonag...@gmail.com, Feb 6, 2012
I've seen audio stop entirely.  Ltng bug was running in background when I started typing this and it did not survive more than 2 to 4 keys. Acer Iconia A500
Comment 263 by NathanHa...@gmail.com, Feb 8, 2012
The audio loop skips for the app Sleepy Time Lite on my Motorola Photon running Gingerbread.  It drives me nuts and essentially defeats the purpose of the app.  I did not have this problem on my Samsung Transform running Froyo.
Comment 264 by culp....@gmail.com, Feb 21 (6 days ago)
Present on my Samsung Captivate running CM9 build 16. I used to use the app Sleepy Time almost every night. Please fix, my wife (iPhone user) is having way too much fun with this... 
Comment 265 by wdav...@gmail.com, Feb 23 (4 days ago)
The workaround I use is checking getCurrentPosition() against getDuration() in my game loop, if we're at the end; rewind using seekTo(0). Nasty, but for now...
Sign in to add a comment

Powered by Google Project Hosting